Alcatraz is more than just a rock in the San Francisco Bay—it’s a historical symbol visited by millions every year. With Donald Trump’s recent directive to reopen Alcatraz as a federal prison for “ruthless and violent offenders,” concerns are rising about the potential loss of heritage and tourism revenue. For decades, Alcatraz has stood as a reminder of America’s complex justice history.
Now, it faces a dramatic transformation that could erase its cultural value. Can history and harsh justice co-exist in the same place? Some say restoring Alcatraz as a prison would erase its legacy, while others argue it’s a strong stance against crime. What’s your take—protect the past or prioritize security? Join the debate.
