As violent crimes rise across some U.S. cities, the search for effective deterrents intensifies. Trump believes that reopening Alcatraz could strike fear into the hearts of repeat violent offenders. The idea: if criminals know they’ll be locked away on a remote, heavily guarded island with zero luxuries, it might change their behavior.
But does fear really work? Some experts argue that crime prevention comes from education, jobs, and community reform—not from high-profile prisons. Others welcome the return of “no mercy” tactics. What do you think—is fear an effective deterrent, or a short-term fix? Cast your vote now.
